Amelia's War by Ann Rinaldi
 

Home

Adolescent Literature Homepage

wpe5.jpg (4333 bytes)

  1.  
  2.  
  3.  

     

    1.  Amelia’s War by Ann Rinaldi     ISBN: 0-590-11744-0

    New York: Scholastic Press, 1999. 265 pages. $15.95 

    2. Historical Novel / Coming of Age                                                         Grades 7-10   

    3. The main characters are Amelia Grafton, her mother and father and two brothers Wes and Sky. Amelia, the eventual heroine, calls herself a Southerner--not a Rebel--for the Union but not for the Yankees. She is an adolescent trying to make sense out of a confusing world.  Josh Dechart is the editor’s son, a friend of Amelia and Wes. He declares he has no interest in the war; he’s only interested in writing truthfully about it at first.  Jinny Pearl Beal is Wesley’s girlfriend, a friend also of Amelia’s, who disguises herself as a boy and joins in fighting on the battlefield.  Aunt Lou is the freed slave, friend and helper of the Grafton family.

    4.  Plot

    This is the story of the Graftons, a shopkeeper and his family who live in Hagerstown, Maryland in 1861. The novel opens at a tea honoring Dewitt Rench, the youthful heartthrob of Williamsport’s girls. Dewitt, regally arrayed in his Confederate uniform, is mercilessly shot down in view of his guests, providing a tragic portent of the coming war.

    Amelia Grafton, a witness to the killing, reports the tragedy to Mr. Dechart, the local newspaper editor. Dechart is imprisoned for writing about the Dewitt Rench incident; his offices and presses are wrecked by a local mob. Soon the war begins.

    As the Civil War progresses, Amelia’s family encounter hardship, change and tragedy as well as adventure. Because of what had happened to Mr. Dechart (Amelia feels partially responsible), Amelia vows to keep her nose out of the terrible war and to just wait for it to be over. Eventually she finds that she cannot remain uninvolved.

    The war disrupts the Grafton’s relationships, loyalties, friendships as soldiers are in and out of town, as boys (and one girl) are running away to join the Armies while fathers are absent from home, as animals are stolen, as farms are ransacked, as caravans, wagons, ambulances crowd the streets and roads, as conflicting reports spread about the carnage of the battlefields, as the war drags endlessly on until finally the town is under siege. Gen. McCausland arrives.

    General McCausland, Josh’s uncle, sends a message to Hagerstown officials that he wants $200,000 in cash plus other supplies or he is going to burn the town of Hagerstown. Since Amelia knows that the town doesn’t have this much money in its treasury, she cleverly changes the General’s order by eliminating one of the zeros (by using white paint) before the document is sent to the town officials; the note is delivered by Josh who is thereby forced to join his uncle’s command. As the piece de resistence the Grafton’s heirloom tea service is added to the cash payment for McCausland. The town is saved by Amelia’s and Josh’s courageous actions. Fortunately, no one ever finds out who changed the amount of money on that order!

    Later Josh loses his life on the battlefield, the price he pays for being the courier for the general’s order. Wes returns home safely from the war and Jinny Pearl does too. The childhood romance ends between Wes and Jinny Pearl. Jinny Pearl leaves Hagerstown.

    The townspeople complain about the McCausland debt on their taxes, but the nightmare of the war ends. Amelia has grown up. She misses her dear friend Josh.

    5.  There are few touchy areas but many excellent topics for writing and discussion.

  • Is anything/everything fair in love and war?
  • Can dishonesty ever be justified?
  • Is it possible to remain neutral in a war?
  • Why did Jinny Pearl disguise herself as a boy in order to fight in the  Civil War? Was this ever done before?
  • Should women soldiers serve in combat? Why or why not?
  • Do individuals react to the same situation in different ways,                    depending on whether they are with a group or are alone? What occurs that turns a group into a mob?
  • Discuss: Does your family possess heirlooms (like the tea set) which may or may not be of appreciable value, that are important to them?
  • What often happens to families when father/mothers/siblings are away at war?
  • What do the women left at home during this time do to help the war effort?
  • What portrayal of war does this novel give?
  • Discuss the relationships of : Amelia and Jinny; Amelia and her brothers; Amelia and her mother and father; Amelia and Josh; Jinny Pearl and Wes.
  • Is it ever justifiable to betray a friend’s confidence? Why or why not?
  • What changes occur in the family’s life due to the war?
  • How are Gen. Robert E. Lee, Gen. McCausland, Gen Custer portrayed? Aunt Lou?
  • What do Sky’s descriptions of the carnage of the battlefield reveal about war?
  • How is the Grafton’s antique silver tea set symbolic?
  • Did you expect Aunt Charlotte to keep the tea set? Why or why not?
  • In what ways is life in 2000 easier/harder than it was in 1861?
  • Explain what you think Amelia’s mother meant when she said that, "the most important thing we ever have to learn in life is to live with our choices."? Do you agree or disagree?
  • At the end of the novel the disgruntled citizens are complaining about the effects of the McCausland debt on their taxes. What unpleasant truth does this reveal about human nature?
  • How has Amelia changed at the end of the novel?

            6. Related Titles (by this author)

Wolf by the Ears (1993), In My Father’s House (1996), An Aquaintance with Darkness (1997), and Cast Two Shadows (1998).

            7.  Movies

Gone With the Wind

                 Music and Poetry                                                                              

from the Civil War available online at users.erols.com/kfraser.

                 Photos and Art

from the Civil War available at www.civil-war.net/photogal.html

                 Websites

GREAT web resource from UVA at jefferson.village.virgina.edu/vshadow2/

Other helpful sites are: www.sunsite.utk.edu/civil-war , www.cwc.lsu.edu , and www.libraries.rutgers.edu/rulib/socsci/hist/civwar-2.html

            8. Evaluation

From a fascinating wartime incident Ann Rinaldi weaves an interesting novel of danger, conflicting loyalties. It reveals the everyday disruptions of life in wartime for the Grafton family. Because the family members are confronted with many moral dilemmas and tough decisions, this story should be of interest to adolescents who are beginning to ask some of the same questions and to make similar decisions themselves. Besides, students will just enjoy the action and characters in the story!  Rating - 9

            9. Reviewed by

Kay Baines, Dallas, TX   rbaines493@aol.com